An independent study by professors at UC Berkeley & the University of Chicago validated the efficiency & savings derived from the use of BURN’s Jikokoa. Expanded highlights from the study:
- Consistent 39% ($2.28/wk) savings through the lifetime of Jikokoa: “The stove reduces charcoal spending by USD 2.28 per week on average, or a decrease of 50 log points, which corresponds to a 39% decrease in charcoal consumption. These results also hold for self-reported weekly charcoal spending during the endline survey. Using data from a pilot experiment conducted in Fall 2018, we confirm that these causal impacts are stable over time, up to 18 months after adoption.”
- $119 per year savings, NPV of $178 for 2 years of ownership: “USD 2.28 per week—USD 119 per year—corresponds to on average one month of respondent income. Net Present Value (NPV) after two years of stove ownership equals USD 178 per respondent, and is positive for > 99% of respondents.”
- Lab stats for savings align with RCT field measurements, a first for cookstoves: “Our empirical estimate aligns closely with ex-ante engineering predictions. The stove manufacturers previously estimated that the efficiency gain from the Jikokoa stove is 43–45% relative to a traditional Kenyan stove. Our point estimate is a 39% reduction with a 95% confidence interval of (30, 48). We therefore cannot rule out that the engineering estimates accurately predict realized savings. This is in contrast to extensive existing empirical work evaluating energy efficiency investments finding realized savings lacking when compared to engineering estimates.”
- Savings are used for critical expenditures to improve quality of life: ”More than 60% of respondents report using the savings for critical household expenditures such as food items and child school fees. This means governments looking to reduce poverty by increasing household adoption of profitable technologies may find that addressing market failures in the credit sector can provide tangible opportunities for welfare gains for poor households.
Return on Investment - Household
- Significant IRR (296% per year): “Savings constitute an average internal rate of return (IRR) of 24.7% per month, or 296% per year. This is larger than almost all available alternatives.”
- IRR is order of magnitude higher than other interventions: “The IRR on the energy-efficient cookstove is an order of magnitude larger the IRR of most relevant alternative investments that are available to respondents in the domains of enterprise, agriculture, and education.”
- Jikokoa is the research-proven single best investment with the highest return that a Kenyan household can make: “We have evaluated existing estimates from the literature of alternative investments that are likely to be available to this population, including investments in healthcare and enterprises. We find very limited evidence that more profitable alternative investments exist.”
Return on Investment – Society/Environment
- Several valuable quantifiable benefits, including CO2 reduction, financial savings, and time savings: The most significant benefits from two years of ownership consist of avoided environmental damages in terms of greenhouse gas emissions (USD 229), financial savings (USD 214), 82-time savings (USD 256), and improvements in health outcomes.”
- Total return to society of $699 for 2 years of use (equivalent to more than $1000 for 3 years of use): “We define ‘private benefits’ to be the sum of financial savings and time savings. This equals USD 470. Finally, we define ‘total benefits’ to be the sum of private benefits and reductions in environmental externalities. The sum of these equals USD 699.”
- Every $1 of subsidy would generate $20 in environmental and poverty returns, indicating the necessity for subsidy and further tax and fee reductions: “We estimate that providing a USD 30 subsidy for the energy-efficient stove has an MVPF of USD 13.71 when factoring in the private benefits alone. This is a highly effective poverty alleviation program even for policymakers that are not concerned with environmental externalities. When avoided environmental damages are included, the MVPF rises to USD 20.38.”
- Quantified improvement in self-reported heath: “Stove adoption causes significant improvements in self-reported health. Adoption of the stove causes a 0.56 standard deviation improvement in health. These health benefits and high take-up rates (after relaxing credit constraints) stand in contrast to a large literature that generally finds that demand for improved cookstoves is low and inelastic to messaging around the potential health benefits.”
"The Jikokoa’s improvement on previous cookstove technologies is likely attributable to the fact that the Jikokoa is incredibly easy to use and requires no learning. It does not require any behavioral change, which is what frequently caused changes in behavior and usage over time among modern cookstoves that have been studied in the past. It is more durable than traditional stoves, and on the rare occasion that the stove breaks down, adopters have access to free repair services provided in low-income areas across Nairobi."
"More than 98% of respondents knew of the stove prior to the study. Second, during the endline 99% of stove adopters say they recommend the stove to friends and family members, and fewer than 1% had ever considered selling it."
Get the full report here.